Pride Spotlight: Lucy Hicks Anderson

Episode Summary

Lucy Hicks Anderson was born Tobias Lawson in Kentucky in 1886. Though assigned male at birth, from a young age she identified as female and insisted on wearing dresses and going by Lucy. Her supportive family embraced raising her as a girl. In her 20s, Lucy moved to Texas and worked at a hotel before relocating to New Mexico where she married Clarence Hicks. After their divorce, Lucy used her savings to purchase a boarding house in California that was a front for an illegal speakeasy and brothel during Prohibition. Lucy was a successful madam and celebrated socialite who hosted lavish parties. In 1944, she married soldier Reuben Anderson but was later charged with perjury for lying about her sex on the marriage license, since same-sex marriage wasn't yet legal. She was convicted and sentenced to probation. Both Lucy and Reuben were also convicted of fraud for receiving military spouse benefits. In jail, Lucy was forbidden from wearing women's clothing. After release, police barred her return to California. Lucy and Reuben moved to Los Angeles where she lived as a woman until her death in 1954 at age 68. Lucy Hicks Anderson was a pioneering transgender woman who refused to hide her identity despite transphobia and racism.

Episode Show Notes

In honor of Pride Month, we're taking every Saturday to re-release a favorite past episode featuring an incredible LGBTQ woman. Each episode will be introduced by an LGBTQ advocate or podcaster we love. Today, Charlotte Clymer is introducing Lucy Hicks Anderson (1886-1954). Lucy was an American socialite, chef, and thriving prohibition-era Madame and entrepreneur. She was also one of the earliest documented African-American transgender people in the United States.

Episode Transcript

SPEAKER_02: Reboot your credit card with Apple Card. It gives you unlimited daily cash back that can earn 4.15% annual percentage yield when you open a savings account. A high yield, low effort way to grow your money with no fees. Apply for Apple Card now in the Wallet app on iPhone to start earning and growing your daily cash with savings today. Apple Card subject to credit approval. Savings is available to Apple Card owners subject to eligibility. Savings accounts by Goldman Sachs Bank USA. Member FDIC, terms apply. SPEAKER_06: Sick of paying $100 for groceries and getting nothing but eggs, orange juice, and a paper bag? Then download the Drop app. Drop lets you earn points with your everyday shopping and redeem them for gift cards. Want a free dinner with those groceries? Drop it. How about daily lattes? Drop it. So download Drop today and get $5 just for signing up. Use invite code GETDROP777. SPEAKER_03: How rude Tanneritos, a Full House rewatch podcast is here. Join us as hosts Jody Sweeten and Andrea Barber look back on their journey together as the iconic characters we all love, Stephanie Tanner and Kimmy Gibbler. Here's a quick preview brought to you by the Hyundai Tucson. We spent our entire childhoods SPEAKER_05: on a little show called Full House. Playing frenemies, but becoming besties whenever the cameras weren't rolling. And now 35 years later, it's our biggest adventure yet. SPEAKER_03: You can listen to How Rude Tanneritos on the iHeartRadio app or wherever you get your podcasts. Brought to you by the Hyundai Tucson. It's your journey. SPEAKER_00: Hello, I'm Charlotte Clymer and my pronouns are she, her, hers. I'm a writer and LGBTQ advocates. And today I'm excited to introduce one of my favorite queer women that's been featured on Encyclopedia Womanica, Lucy Hicks Anderson. She is a remarkable example of a strong and proud trans woman who refused to back down from her authenticity, not only dealing with transphobia, but as a black woman dealing with violent white supremacy. Her story is incredibly inspiring from her childhood to when she was put on trial and compelled to die who she was. And she refused to do that. I think it's especially important to tell this story during Pride Month because the modern LGBTQ rights movement is built on the backs of strong and proud trans women of color, especially black trans women. Now here's host Jenny Kaplan to tell you about Lucy Hicks Anderson. SPEAKER_01: Hello, from Wonder Media Network, I'm Jenny Kaplan and this is Encyclopedia Womanica. Welcome to a brand new month and therefore a brand new theme. All May, we're talking about mavericks and legends. Women who are known or should be known for seriously challenging gender norms and turning societal or class expectations on their heads. The women in this group often overcame major disadvantages. Some of these women wielded great power for better or for worse. Others accomplished incredible feats despite limits on their agency or ability. This theme is a bit more complex than some of our previous months, but hopefully it'll prove very much worth the journey. Today's legend was an American socialite, chef, and thriving prohibition era madam and entrepreneur. She was one of the earliest documented African-American transgender people in the United States. Please welcome Lucy Hicks Anderson. Tobias Lawson was born in Wadi, Kentucky in 1886. Though assigned male at birth, from her earliest years, she adamantly self-identified as female. By the time she started school, she insisted on wearing dresses and going by the name Lucy. Concerned with what was going on with her child in an era before the term transgender was in our lexicon, Lucy's mother took her to see a physician. Interestingly, in light of the times, the doctor told Lucy's parents that the best course of action was simply to let her live as a woman, so they did. From that point forward, they fully embraced raising Lucy as a girl, and they were highly supportive of her. When Lucy was 15, she left school to join the workforce as a domestic. Five years later, Lucy moved from Kentucky down to Pecos, Texas, where she worked at a local hotel for 10 years. Then in 1920, she moved to Silver City, New Mexico, where she met and married a man named Clarence Hicks. Lucy was 34 at the time. After their wedding, Lucy and Clarence left New Mexico to move to Oxnard, California, where Lucy once again found work as a domestic. There, Lucy began making a name for herself by winning a number of baking competitions. She was also celebrated around town as a talented chef. In 1929, Lucy and Clarence divorced. Now on her own, Lucy used her life savings to purchase property close to the center of town. It wasn't just any property. It was a boarding house front for a brothel that also sold liquor, then illegal under prohibition. Lucy was a very successful madam. Her brothel and drinking establishment was a well-known and well-used community establishment. During her free time, Lucy was a celebrated hostess and socialite in town, well-known for throwing lavish dinner parties and being heavily involved in many of the town's charitable and civic organizations. She used these friendships and connections with important members of Oxnard society to get her out of trouble with the law. Scholar C. Riley Snorton wrote, "'When the sheriff arrested her one night, her double-barreled reputation paid off. Charles Donlon, the town's leading banker, promptly bailed her out. He had scheduled a large dinner party which would have collapsed dismally with Lucy in jail.'" In 1944, Lucy married a man named Reuben Anderson, an American soldier who was stationed at Mitchell Field in Long Island, New York. A year later, in 1945, a sailor visiting Oxnard claimed that he'd caught a venereal disease from one of the women working in Lucy's brothel. As a result, all of the women working at the brothel were required to undergo medical examinations by the local doctor. This order included Lucy herself. When the local district attorney learned from the examination that Lucy was assigned male at birth, he decided to charge her with perjury for lying about her sex on her recent marriage certificate and for impersonating a woman. During her trial, Lucy stated, "'I defy any doctor in the world to prove that I am not a woman. I have lived, dressed, acted just what I am, a woman.' Still, she was convicted of perjury relating to her marriage license and received a sentence of 10 years probation. Because only marriages between men and women were legally recognized at the time, Lucy's marriage was also deemed invalid as a result of the conviction, as she was now legally considered a man. In a final gut punch, in 1946, the federal government decided to charge both Lucy and Reuben with fraud for receiving money allotted to wives of soldiers under the GI Bill. Lucy was also initially charged with failing to register for the military draft, but that was eventually dropped. Both Lucy and Reuben were found guilty of the fraud charge and were sentenced to prison. By order of the court, Lucy was also forbidden from wearing women's clothing while incarcerated. SPEAKER_01: After serving their time, Lucy and Reuben tried to move back to Oxnard, but were barred by order of the police chief, who threatened further prosecution if Lucy returned. Instead, the couple moved to Los Angeles, where they resided together until Lucy's death in 1954. She was 68 years old. All month, we're talking about mavericks and legends. For more on why we're doing what we're doing, check out our newsletter, Wamanica Weekly. You can also follow us on Facebook and Instagram at encyclopediawamanica, and you can follow me directly on Twitter at Jennie M. Kaplan. Special thanks to Liz Kaplan, my favorite sister and co-creator. Talk to you soon. SPEAKER_02: Evidence-wise, we have virtually no evidence. SPEAKER_05: In 1995, Detective Tony Richardson was trying to figure out who killed a fellow officer. The case comes down to who is believed and who is ignored. Oh my goodness, we did convict an innocent man. I'm Beth Shelburne from Lava for Good podcasts. This is Ear Witness. Listen to Ear Witness on the iHeartRadio app, Apple podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. SPEAKER_07: Coming to Hulu this Friday and Saturday night. Don't miss our 2023 iHeartRadio music festival. The biggest superstars from all genres of music on one stage. Foo Fighters, Fallout Boy, Kelly Clarkson, Lenny Kravitz, Travis Scott, Tim McGraw, TLC, and more. From T-Mobile Arena in Las Vegas, it's the can't miss music event of the year. Our iHeartRadio music festival. Stream it live only on Hulu and listen on iHeartRadio stations. Friday night and Saturday night, starting at 10 p.m. Eastern, 7 p.m. Pacific. SPEAKER_04: Harper Wild is creating a more comfortable world for womankind. Starting with the world's most comfortable bras and underwear, which are tested by real people with real bodies who say things like, it feels like clouds or holding up my ladies or the holy grail of bras. And you'll have to pry these bras out of my cold dead hands. That comfortable. Get $15 off your order with code comfy at harperwild.com. That's code comfy at harperwild.com.