Folk Heroes: Eliza Donnithorne

Episode Summary

The podcast episode discusses Eliza Donathon, a woman who lived in Sydney, Australia in the 19th century. Eliza was born around 1826 and was the youngest daughter of a merchant. She grew up traveling the world with her family before they settled in Sydney in a mansion called Camperdown Lodge. After her mother died and brothers moved away, it was just Eliza and her father. After her father died in 1852, legend has it that Eliza was left at the altar on her wedding day at around age 30. Her groom never arrived and the guests eventually left. Eliza continued to wait for her groom, wearing her wedding dress, allowing the house to fall into disrepair around her. She became a recluse for the next 30 years until her death in 1886. The truth is that not much is actually known about why Eliza was a recluse. She did leave her estate to her housekeeper when she died and was known to be kind to animals. She was likely just an eccentric older woman that her neighbors didn't know well, so rumors spread. Some have speculated her story inspired Charles Dickens' character Miss Havisham in Great Expectations. But the novel was published only about 5 years after Eliza's alleged failed wedding, so it's unlikely he knew about her story. More likely, the popular Dickens novel reinforced the myth around Eliza after it was published. In the end, Eliza Donathon was probably not a scorned bride, but rather a mysterious recluse whose story grew more mythical over time.

Episode Show Notes

Eliza Donnithorne (1821-1886) was an infamous recluse. Legend has it she was abandoned on her wedding day, and she never recovered. Her story may have inspired one of literature’s most famous scorned brides: Miss Havisham of Dickens' Great Expectations.

Episode Transcript

SPEAKER_01: Reboot your credit card with Apple Card. It gives you unlimited daily cash back that can earn 4.15% annual percentage yield when you open a savings account. A high yield, low effort way to grow your money with no fees. Apply for Apple Card now in the Wallet app on iPhone to start earning and growing your daily cash with savings today. Apple Card subject to credit approval. Savings is available to Apple Card owners subject to eligibility. Savings accounts by Goldman Sachs Bank USA. Member FDIC, terms apply. SPEAKER_03: Sick of paying $100 for groceries and getting nothing but eggs, orange juice, and a paper bag? Then download the Drop app. Drop lets you earn points with your everyday shopping and redeem them for gift cards. Want a free dinner with those groceries? Drop it. How about daily lattes? Drop it. So download Drop today and get $5 just for signing up. Use invite code GETDROP777. SPEAKER_00: Hello, from Wonder Media Network, I'm Jenny Kaplan, and this is Womanica. This month we're talking about folk heroes, women whose lives and stories have taken on mythic proportions. Today we're talking about an infamous recluse. Legend has it she was abandoned on her wedding day and she never recovered. Her story may have inspired one of literature's most famous scorned brides. Let's talk about Eliza Donathon. Our story takes place in an old house called Camperdown Lodge in Sydney. Inside, paint and plaster flaked off the walls. Outside, there were overgrown bushes and rusted shutters. Neighbors knew better than to come calling at the old mansion, even if the door was propped open a few inches. The old Miss Eliza Donathon couldn't come to the door. Nobody but her housekeepers and attendants had seen her in decades. When the neighbors talked, as all neighbors do, about the reclusive old woman at the end of Georgina Street, they tended to fill in the details for themselves. What we do know is Eliza Emily Donathon was the youngest daughter of a seafaring merchant. Eliza was born around 1826 in South Africa. Her early life was spent traveling the world with her family before they finally settled in Australia. The Donathorns moved into Camperdown Lodge and, by all accounts, it was a happy place. The house echoed with laughter, and Eliza's father was known all around Sydney for his hospitality. Eliza grew into a young woman. Her brothers joined the army and moved away. Her mother died young. Eventually, it was just Eliza and her father in the big, beautiful house, until he, too, died in 1852. Here's where the speculation begins. In some tales, Eliza was engaged to be married in 1856, when she was 30 years old. In others, it was a few years earlier, when her father was still alive. Either way, the day of the wedding came and everything was set. The house was abuzz with preparations. The wedding breakfast was set on a grand table with tarts and jams as far as the eye could see. Eliza was ready in her gown, waiting for her groom to show. She waited and waited. Guests grew hungry, but Eliza didn't let them touch the breakfast table. Maybe he had an accident, got lost, was running late, but he would come. Eliza insisted he would. Eventually, the guests grew tired of waiting, and one by one, they left. But Eliza wouldn't grow tired. She would wait and wait and wait. After that, Eliza became a recluse. The wedding breakfast went untouched. It molded and decayed and turned to dust. The giant house, where time stopped for Eliza, crumbled all around her. Eliza waited for 30 more years, still wearing her wedding gown until the day she died in 1886. The front door, which remained ajar for decades, in hopes that her lost love would return, was finally closed. At least, that's what the neighbors would say. The truth is that no one really knows why old Miss Dona Thorne hid from the world. She was an older woman, never married, and she was left in charge of her father's estate after his passing. It's true that Eliza was reclusive and that her neighbors didn't see much of her. We also have records that show her benevolence. She left most of her estate to her housekeeper, Sarah Ann Bailey. She also left a lot of money to the Society for Prevention of Cruelty to Animals in Sydney. The truth is, she was probably an eccentric older lady that the neighbors didn't know much about. So why the jilted bride tale? That's where Charles Dickens comes in. Eliza Dona Thorne's tale is a familiar one, especially if you've read any 19th-century classic novels. She's strikingly similar to another famous scorned bride, Miss Havisham, from Great Expectations. For many years, people have asked, did Eliza's story inspire Dickens to create the character? Great Expectations was published in 1861 and follows the life of an orphan boy named Pip. In his childhood, he meets Miss Havisham, an older woman who was left on her wedding day. Like Miss Dona Thorne, Miss Havisham is reclusive. She always wears her wedding dress, and she lives in a dilapidated house. Unlike Miss Dona Thorne, Miss Havisham is vengeful, making Pip fall in love with her adopted daughter just so she can reject him and hurt him, like Miss Havisham was hurt. Eliza Dona Thorne, according to reports from the time, didn't leave her house much, but she also didn't bother anyone. Eliza was kind to her housekeepers and her animals. She was an eccentric older lady who inspired curiosity in her neighbors. It's unlikely that Eliza inspired the character of Miss Havisham. The novel was published only about five years after Eliza's supposed wedding would have taken place. There's also no evidence that Charles Dickens knew anything about hyper-local Australian lore. If anything, it was the other way around. What likely happened is that the Dickens novel, which was very popular in its time, filled in the gaps for people who wondered about Eliza Dona Thorne, the reclusive camper-down lodge. An unmarried woman was a novelty at the time. An unmarried wealthy woman was even more intriguing. The story of the scorned bride-to-be probably felt more logical than any other explanation as to why she ended up alone. Plus, if there's one thing people love more than a ghost story, it's a ghosting story. All month, we're talking about folk heroes. For more information, find us on Facebook and Instagram at Womanica Podcast. Special thanks to Liz Kaplan, my favorite sister and co-creator. Talk to you tomorrow. SPEAKER_05: AT&T and Verizon lure you in with their best phone offers, only to lock you into a three-year phone contract, not at T-Mobile. Now, with T-Mobile's best Go 5G plans, upgrade when you want. Every year or every two, you decide. Visit T-Mobile.com to take charge of your upgrades. SPEAKER_06: Get two-year financing on Go 5G Plus and Next. One-year upgrade on Go 5G Next requires financing a new qualifying device and upgrading in good condition after six plus months with 50% paid off. Upgrade ends financing in any promo credits. Visit AT&T.com. SPEAKER_04: Your home is important. It's where you raise your family and your biggest financial investment. For your home improvement projects, visit iHeart.dibella.us for your roofing, siding, window, and bath renovations. In your community, there's a local Dibella team. Visit iHeart.dibella.us for your free no obligation quote. It's easy. There's no payments until 2024 on approved credit. Over 15,000 satisfied customers on Google had a five-star experience with Dibella. For your home improvement projects, check out the award-winning pros at iHeart.dibella.us where quality begins at home. SPEAKER_02: Harper Wild is creating a more comfortable world for womankind, starting with the world's most comfortable bras and underwear, which are tested by real people with real bodies who say things like, it feels like clouds or holding up my ladies or the holy grail of bras and you'll have to pry these bras out of my cold dead hands that comfortable. Get $15 off your order with code comfy at harperwild.com. That's code comfy at harperwild.com.