Plaid: Articles of Interest #2

Episode Summary

Paragraph 1: The episode discusses the history and cultural significance of tartan patterns, often referred to as "plaid" in the US. Tartan originated as a parochial pattern worn by Highlanders in Scotland. It was used on traditional garments like kilts and plaids. After tartan was banned in Scotland in 1746, it became trendy and was appropriated by other groups like English aristocrats and American colonists. This spread tartan's popularity globally. Paragraph 2: During the ban, Scottish soldiers deployed around the British Empire spread the influence of tartan. It inspired similar patterns like Madras fabric. When the ban was lifted in 1782, tartan became hugely popular. Around 1810, clan leaders started assigning official clan tartans, though these were largely invented. Tartan manufacturing boomed as an export to America, where it represented heritage. Enslaved people also wore tartan. Paragraph 3: Today tartan is ubiquitous, used by many groups and nationalities. There are tartans for states, corporations, individuals, pets, and more. The Scottish Register of Tartans gets many proposals, mostly from North America. Tartan allows people, especially in America, to claim a sense of identity and belonging. The pattern's meaning has evolved, but retains a sense of heritage.

Episode Show Notes

Lots of different groups have adopted plaid over the course of the 20th century, but if we want to explore how this pattern proliferated, we’ve got to go to Scotland.

Episode Transcript

SPEAKER_03: AppleCard is the perfect credit card for every purchase. It has cash-back rewards unlike others. You earn unlimited daily cash back on every purchase, receive it daily, and can grow it at a 4.15% annual percentage yield when you open a high-yield savings account. Apply for AppleCard in the Wallet app on iPhone and start earning and growing your daily cash with savings today. AppleCard subject to credit approval, savings is available to AppleCard owners subject to eligibility requirements. Savings accounts provided by Goldman Sachs Bank USA. Member FDIC. Charms apply. Every kid learns differently, so it's really important that your children have the educational support that they need to help them keep up and excel. If your child needs homework help, check out iXcel, the online learning platform for kids. iXcel covers math, language arts, science, and social studies through interactive practice problems from pre-K to 12th grade. As kids practice, they get positive feedback and even awards. With the school year ramping up, now is the best time to get iXcel. Our listeners can get an exclusive 20% off iXcel membership when they sign up today at ixcel.com slash invisible. That's the letters ixl.com slash invisible. Squarespace is the all-in-one platform for building your brand and growing your business online. Stand out with a beautiful website, engage with your audience, and sell anything. Your products, content you create, and even your time. You can easily display posts from your social profiles on your website or share new blogs or videos to social media. Automatically push website content to your favorite channels so your followers can share it too. Go to squarespace.com slash invisible for a free trial and when you're ready to launch, use the offer code invisible to save 10% off your first purchase of a website or domain. SPEAKER_04: I couldn't figure it out. I was hitting on a lot of straight people. SPEAKER_06: This is Annapoli. She's a writer and when she moved from Chicago to San Francisco, she didn't know who to hit on anymore. SPEAKER_04: Midwestern queer culture is extremely different than Bay Area queer culture. And one of the things that was most noticeable to me was fashion. SPEAKER_06: Some of the queer signals from the Midwest didn't quite hold, like plaid flannel shirts. SPEAKER_04: I wear flannel and I feel gayer. In the Midwest, way more so, I think. SPEAKER_06: If you are part of a group, there are things you can wear or ways you can style your hair, signs that show that you are part of that group. SPEAKER_04: Flannel is one way to signify like I exist. But you can't really stop other people from wearing these signals. SPEAKER_06: And so eventually the power of that signal gets diluted. So if you see someone wearing plaid now, does it mean anything to you? SPEAKER_04: Well I might first think, are you a bike messenger? SPEAKER_06: And then the next thing you know, you can't even tell what clothing is signaling what anymore. SPEAKER_04: Yeah, one night I was rebuffed by this straight lady and I got upset about it. And also I'd been thinking about hipsters a lot because they appropriate a lot of working class culture motifs. And flannel is one of them. SPEAKER_06: So it doesn't seem like lesbians are appropriating working class wear? SPEAKER_04: Yeah, so that's an interesting, I don't know who actually owns, you know. If anyone can own a fabric. SPEAKER_06: Articles of interest. A show about what we wear. And so maybe the idea is about clothing. SPEAKER_05: You can attach. SPEAKER_08: Our idea is about class. An idea of home to a piece of cloth. These are best for last. SPEAKER_04: Any fool can wear clothes. SPEAKER_00: But if you ain't got the attitude and the style to carry it off, man you're just a clothes boss. SPEAKER_06: Lumberjacks wore plaid. Punks wore plaid miniskirts. The Beach Boys, I kid you not, used to be called the Pendletones and they wore plaid with their surfboards. So many different groups have adopted plaid, so it almost doesn't mean anything anymore. And really, why are we all wearing this? This particular pattern, which once upon a time was mostly concentrated in the upper corner of this one island off the coast of Europe. SPEAKER_09: Certainly for Scotland, it's dress. Dress is the thing that identifies people in Scotland. Dress people say bagpipes as well. SPEAKER_06: This is Peter MacDonald, historian at the Scottish Tartans Authority. They call this pattern tartan, not plaid. SPEAKER_09: We don't use that word for patterns in this country. Plaid is a garment. SPEAKER_06: The Scotsman who lived in the Highlands, the northern hilly part of the country, used to wrap themselves in a cloth, almost like a blanket, kind of like an Indian sari. SPEAKER_09: So if you like it's a tartan sari, would be the nearest equivalent. SPEAKER_06: That bolt of cloth was called a plaid and it had a tartan pattern on it. SPEAKER_09: That's how the term got into the U.S. and that word then becomes synonymous with the pattern. SPEAKER_06: It's not like back then there were tartan shirts and tartan scarves. No, tartan was on these traditional plaids and overcoats and on the traditional pants, which were called trues. SPEAKER_09: Trues are tartan trousers, but they're not trousers because they're tights, they included the feet. So they're more like ladies tights, you know. SPEAKER_06: So tartan was kind of this parochial little pattern that Scotsmen in the country used to wear. And it was pretty much only used on these obscure traditional Highland garments that I had never heard of before. And then something happened. Something that would end up turning tartan loose on the world. These obscure traditional Highland clothes were banned. SPEAKER_09: The act banned kilts, plaids, and other elements of Highland dress and outdoor coats in tartan you can't wear as well. SPEAKER_06: The act Peter Macdonald is talking about is the Dress Act of 1746. Scotland was being taken over by the Hanoverian Empire. And many of the Scots who fought back were from the Highlands. And so they wore tartan coats and kilts and plaids. SPEAKER_09: Put in modern parlance, they would be seen as terrorists or freedom fighters, depending on which side you were on. But that's the reason for the ban. SPEAKER_06: It was a way to suppress the resistance by limiting what they wore. Men were not allowed to wear Highland clothes for 35 years in Scotland. But here's the thing. Just like banned books become the cool thing to read, when Scottish clothes were banned, they became the cool thing to wear. SPEAKER_08: As always, when you're not allowed to wear something, that means somebody else immediately will. SPEAKER_06: This is Jonathan Fares, author of the book Tartan. And he says what the ban did was that it made Highland clothes trendy outside of Scotland. Suddenly, tartan was also being worn in England. SPEAKER_08: That moment made tartan a fashionable fabric. It was no longer a sign of indigenous Highlanders. It became something that perhaps lowlanders or English people with Scottish sympathy started to wear. SPEAKER_06: But Scottish men had an option. If they wanted to keep wearing their traditional clothes during the ban, there was a loophole. They could go fight for the British Empire. The ban didn't apply to Scotsmen who joined the army. SPEAKER_09: So over time, it encouraged people if they wanted to continue to wear their native garb to join the military. SPEAKER_06: This meant Scotsmen wearing tartans were deployed around the world, which influenced the style and popularity of similar looking patterns across the colonies, like Madras in India, SPEAKER_06: and checkered bandanas in Jamaica, and the shukha cloth of the Maasai warriors. The colonialism of the British Empire spread these influences around and increased global demand for tartan and tartan-like fabrics. SPEAKER_08: The presence of highland regimental soldiers wearing tartan in some form or another would have influenced people directly on a purely aesthetic way. SPEAKER_06: And meanwhile, people in England with Scottish sympathies all got together in 1778 and made a kind of booster group to advocate for Scottish culture. SPEAKER_09: Something called the Highland Society of London was formed in order to try and preserve the customs and manners of what was called the Highland Revival, the Great Highland Revival. They were responsible for the repeal of the Dress Act in 1782. SPEAKER_06: And so by the time the dress ban was finally lifted, it was just like tartan mania. The Great Highland Revival was in full swing. Scottish soldiers were coming home, and now they could wear their tartan, and Englishmen were wearing tartan, and people all over the colonies were wearing tartan, and North Americans were really wearing tartan. SPEAKER_08: Obviously the kind of work shirt that you would particularly identify with America, as you say, a kind of plaid working shirt. If you go back, some of the earliest cloths that were used to make those work shirts were exported from Scotland. SPEAKER_06: Tartan became a massive export to the United States. SPEAKER_09: Tartan was a huge export to America in the 1700s, early 1800s. SPEAKER_06: In the United States, tartan was also a symbol of heritage and belonging. If you were a Scotsman who was made to flee your homeland, or if you literally belonged to a Scotsman. There were lots of very powerful Scottish families very active in the slave trade. SPEAKER_06: These kinds of records are hard to find, but it's said that enslaved people across the colonies also wore tartan-patterned cloth, because tartan is bright and noticeable. Those would be made to wear a cloth with a particular tartan, which said who they belonged to. SPEAKER_08: You were being marked, you were being branded by your owners, by your oppressors, which is pretty chilling. But it certainly, for those people, was very much a cloth of oppression. SPEAKER_06: Tartan has been, in many ways, a cloth of oppression, whether the Scots were being oppressed themselves, or acting as the hand of the British Empire, or perpetuating the global slave trade. And it functions efficiently as a cloth of oppression because it is so loud and highly visible. SPEAKER_08: I do think it has this idea of almost negating the body and becoming literally just the pattern, so you are literally kind of becoming the brand. SPEAKER_06: And tartan can be a brand of so many different conflicting things. In the United States, tartan can be a nod to a rugged Highlander. SPEAKER_08: The idea of the incredibly macho Highlander, who's running around, maybe looking after his sheep, only wearing a kilt. SPEAKER_06: Or a monarchic colonizer. SPEAKER_08: Quintessentially American designers, such as Ralph Lauren, for example, frequently use tartan. I think it is probably associated with ideas of colonialism and empire. SPEAKER_06: And that's aside from its associations with queerness or lumberjacks or cowboys or bike messengers. Quite literally, there's a tartan for everything. SPEAKER_07: These are the tartan swatches. SPEAKER_06: Dee Williams works at the National Records of Scotland. SPEAKER_07: In these boxes here. SPEAKER_06: And she is showing me the Scottish register of tartans, which is very much not open to the public. How often does someone come to? They don't. That's the point. SPEAKER_07: You are the first, well. SPEAKER_06: She said I was the first journalist who had been in there. Generally, we don't offer this. SPEAKER_07: We don't say to people, come in and look at all this swatches. Anybody can look online, by the way, they can look up every tartan online that is in that register. They just need to put in a search. They just need to put in a name and it will come back. SPEAKER_06: Tartans traditionally have been associated with Scottish names. So if your last name is Maclean or McCowan or Hanny, you can look up the traditional tartans associated with your clan. SPEAKER_07: I had the clan chief, Dr. David Hanny, came in today and he was looking up his Hanny tartans. SPEAKER_06: But it's not like everyone who lives in Scotland has this long family history with a traditional last name and a family tartan. And in Scotland, people wear tartan kilts to weddings and funerals and parties. And so what are you supposed to wear if you're not from a clan? SPEAKER_07: That's where you get other people. They've got personal tartans. Personal tartans for? For themselves. They've designed a tartan. They really want it just for them. You've also got organization, corporate ones, lots of military ones being registered lately. No matter who you are or how not Scottish you are, I will bet money that if you peruse SPEAKER_06: the register of tartans, you will eventually find a tartan for something that you like or can identify with. SPEAKER_07: The zoo panda one. SPEAKER_06: The panda at the Edinburgh Zoo has a tartan. It's not like it has pandas on it. It's still just a tartan, but it's black and white. So these are some heritage. There's a San Francisco tartan. That one. The San Francisco tartan is sandy and scarlet like the colors of the 49ers. New Jersey's tartan is sand and blue and little slender bits of red. Most states in the US have an official tartan and a lot of countries have one. Zimbabwe, New Zimbabwe, Kenya. Oh wow, this is the Africa folder. Volkswagen, American Express and Coca-Cola have tartans. Nike has a couple. And there is a tartan for the Scottish register of tartans. There is a Scottish register of tartan tartan? Yes. You could have your very own official tartan. The certificate costs 70 pounds and it's 100 pounds if you want it in a wooden frame. But you'll get the tartan name, you'll get the registration number. SPEAKER_06: You can design your own tartan in literally 10 minutes. Because official tartans don't have to be cloth anymore. Online tartan generator. You can go to any number of online tartan generators. Create a unique business, club or personal plaid. And input the colors you want. Choose palette and the thread count. I can adjust the thickness. And tada! You have a tartan. Now it's just saving my tartan. SPEAKER_09: You'll get tartan people designing a tartan for their dog, you know, or their dead relative. And you know, thinking why? SPEAKER_06: Our historian friend Peter MacDonald is part of the committee that assesses the incoming tartans. They get around eight proposals a week. SPEAKER_09: Quite a lot of what I would call vanity tartans. They're never going to be woven. They're never going to be worn. And it's because they can. You know, which doesn't make them good or tasteful or meaningful, frankly. SPEAKER_06: I mean, do some of these tartans get denied? Yes. And of the new incoming tartans, the majority of them are not from Scotland. On top of my head, 70% come from North America, probably most from the US, but a sizable proportion SPEAKER_09: from Canada as well. Quite a few from Japan. A lot of Japanese schools seem to like tartans with uniforms. And indeed some from Scotland. But yeah, the majority of them come from America. SPEAKER_06: America is really into tartan. I mean, just go to New York City on April 6th. That's National Tartan Day. And they put on this huge parade with bagpipes and Scottish terriers and Scottish associations from all over the US. Tartan is one way that white people can claim some sort of cultural heritage. SPEAKER_09: Because you're a young country, you all want to claim your heritage. And actually a lot of people claim either Scots or Irish ancestry because it has the cultural icons and identity which help you belong. SPEAKER_06: And everyone wants to belong to something, somewhere, somehow. There was about a 30% increase last year of tartans registered. SPEAKER_07: So it's definitely on the increase. SPEAKER_06: In some ways, if you don't get your tartan actually woven, the register of tartans might seem like a cheesy thrill, like one of those online services where you can pay to register a star or buy a plot of land on the moon. But those authentic clan tartans, the ones that represent last names, those were also kind of made up. SPEAKER_08: When you look actually at early examples of surviving tartans, it would not really have been associated with particular families. SPEAKER_09: And there is no way that 600, 1200 people, clansmen, could all be wearing the same tartan. SPEAKER_06: This idea of official clan tartans was part of the Great Highland Revival. SPEAKER_09: Gosh, clan tartans start around 1810. Okay, yes, 200 years is old. SPEAKER_06: But that's nothing when you compare it to the ages of the clans themselves. The Macduffes, the Macdugles, the Macquaries, the McCallens, those are closer to 1000 years old. But basically, in the 1800s, many of the clan leaders just went and picked out tartans they liked and renamed them after themselves. This is kind of like what's your favorite? SPEAKER_09: Yeah, absolutely. Yep. You know, the Campbell chief used the Black Quarche tartan, the chief of the Mackenzie used the 78th or Seaforth tartan, and the MacPherson sealed as his true clan tartan, a tartan that 10 years earlier had been being sold as Caledonia. SPEAKER_06: Tartan, plaid, whatever you want to call it. The pattern has taken on so many different meanings and associations, and it has been used symbolically to unite so many different groups of people. On the surface, the pattern seems simple, right? It's just a series of overlapping threads, a warp and a weft. But really, if you look at it and get your nose right up close and notice the number of colors, the stripe width, the variation in the ways the threads overlap, you can see it's quite complex. And it can be particular enough to be specific and general enough to be for everyone. SPEAKER_04: I mean, just yeah, like cultural recognition, just visibility, being able to walk down the street and be like, oh, that's another person who's like me, I feel this alone. Like that can be something that plaid does, which is kind of amazing if you think about a fabric and having power culturally. SPEAKER_06: Articles of Interest is made by myself, Avery Truffleman, edited by Joe Rosenberg, bagpiping by David Watson, other music by Ray Royal, and intro and outro themes by Sasami Ashworth. Fact Check by Graham Haysha, mixed by Kelly Coyne, and Roman Mars is the macho Highlander of this whole series. A very special thanks to Crystal Benes, Isabel Sloan, Rachel White, Ira Galtman, Christina Stokes and Ian Ferguson, as well as Katie Mingle, Emmett Fitzgerald, Sharif Yousif, Vivian Lee, Delaney Hall, Kurt Kohlstedt, and the whole 99PI team. SPEAKER_01: SPEAKER_03: The International Rescue Committee works in more than 40 countries to serve people whose lives have been upended by conflict and disaster. Over 110 million people are displaced around the world, and the IRC urgently needs your help to meet this unprecedented need. The IRC aims to respond within 72 hours after an emergency strikes, and they stay as long as they are needed. Some of the IRC's most important work is addressing the inequalities facing women and girls, ensuring safety from harm, improving health outcomes, increasing access to education, improving economic well-being, and ensuring women and girls have the power to influence decisions that affect their lives. Generous people around the world give to the IRC to help families affected by humanitarian crises with emergency supplies. Your generous donation will give the IRC steady, reliable support, allowing them to continue their ongoing humanitarian efforts even as they respond to emergencies. Donate today by visiting rescue.org slash rebuild. Visit now and help refugee families in need. Article believes in delightful design for every home, and thanks to their online-only model, they have some really delightful prices, too. Their curated assortment of mid-century modern coastal, industrial, and Scandinavian designs make furniture shopping simple. Article's team of designers are all about finding the perfect balance between style, quality, and price. They're dedicated to thoughtful craftsmanship that stands the test of time and looks good doing it. Article's knowledgeable customer care team is there when you need them to make sure your experience is smooth and stress-free. I think my favorite piece of furniture in my house is the geome sideboard. Maslow picked it out. Remember Maslow? And I keep my vinyl records and CDs in it. It just is awesome. I love the way it looks. Article is offering 99% invisible listeners $50 off your first purchase of $100 or more. To claim, visit article.com slash 99, and the discount will be automatically applied at checkout. That's article.com slash 99 for $50 off your first purchase of $100 or more. SPEAKER_03: This show is sponsored by BetterHelp. Do you ever find that just as you're trying to fall asleep, your brain suddenly won't stop talking? Your thoughts are just racing around? I call this just going to bed. It basically happens every night. It turns out one great way to make those racing thoughts go away is to talk them through. Therapy gives you a place to do that, so you can get out of your negative thought cycles and find some mental and emotional peace. If you're thinking of starting therapy, give BetterHelp a try. It's entirely online, designed to be convenient, flexible, and suited to your schedule. Just fill out a brief questionnaire to get matched with a licensed therapist, and switch therapists at any time for no additional charge. Get a break from your thoughts with BetterHelp. Visit BetterHelp.com slash invisible today to get 10% off your first month. That's BetterHelp. H-E-L-P dot com slash invisible. SPEAKER_06: Scots are really adamant that kilts are not skirts. But there's this one important way that kilts are very similar to women's wear. What are you wearing right now? SPEAKER_05: So I'm wearing my kilt, which is a MacPherson ancient tartan, my kilt shoes, kilt brogues, and then to the top of it I've got a Jurassic Park t-shirt. SPEAKER_06: This is David MacPherson, who I met outside a bar in Edinburgh, and when he wears his kilt, he also has to wear something called a sporran. So what's a sporran? SPEAKER_05: A sporran is a big furry purse. It's a fur and leather purse that sits right over the crotch. SPEAKER_05: And it kind of hangs on a chain around your hips. That attaches to your belt. That attaches to your belt. Because kilts don't have any pockets, so you need to keep your stuff somewhere. So right now I've got my phone in it, I've got my keys, I've got my wallet. Other people, I don't know, they might keep Braveheart on DVD or... I would prefer pockets. I mean, it's not, you can't get very much in it. SPEAKER_06: Your next article of interest is pockets. SPEAKER_02: Thank you. SPEAKER_01: With threats to our nation waiting around every corner, adaptability is more important than ever. When conditions change without notice, quick strategic thinking is crucial. And with obstacles consistently impending, determination is essential in overcoming them. It's this willingness, decisiveness, and resilience that sets Marines apart. With our fighting spirit, we don't just fight battles, we win them. Marines are the constant our nation counts on to fight the unknown. And through adaptable problem solving, we do just that. Learn more at Marines.com. SPEAKER_09: With the McDonald's app, you can get your favorite thing delivered to your door so you can eat your favorite thing while you watch your favorite thing at home. Order McDonald's in the McDonald's app. At participating McDonald's, delivery prices may be higher than at restaurants. SPEAKER_01: Another piece may apply.